Author |
File Description |
Kralramazanov |
Posted on 05/14/11 @ 06:41 AM
File Details |
Style: |
Mix |
Number of scenarios: |
1 |
Needs AoC?: |
No |
Islam was borned.
It's about first Islamic era.
You'll lead to your small Muslim city and you will get back the Kabe, you will fight against Byzantine and you will win.
Sounds are good. I think.
Very fantastic and filled with actions. |
Pages: [1] 2 » Last » |
Author | Comments & Reviews ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only ) |
---|
Kralramazanov
File Author |
Posted on 05/26/11 @ 11:54 AM
Did you like it ? |
aleksandar_s |
Posted on 05/30/11 @ 05:03 PM
Islam was Borned is a scenario about the birth of Islam. The scenario starts more like a RPG game but quickly changes into a force-on-force. Nothing new here. I think we have seen this already but slightly branded differently.
Playability: 4.1
Not bad, but there is no new feature that is really fun. Converting was confusing at fist and I would have liked more in-depth instructions. The scenario was fun, dont get me wrong, it was just same as all other scenarios. Collecting resources was boring, perhaps we could have had some variation on the market system. Arabs are skilled merchants.
Balance: 3.5
What can I say? Rather easy. No real way to loose. Just build up an army and destroy a enemy force that does not change. Dont get me wrong, I dont like scenarios that are too hard, but I dont like ones that are too easy.
Creativity: 3.6
Some points for the story, but besides that, there really is nothing that is new from all the others. Let me give you an example, venice v.1 is one of the highest rated scenarios at EEH, because it is so radical and new. It was the first of it's kind. You dont have to do something crazy, just make it stand out with a new feature.
Map Design: 3.9
Most of it was good, but elevation was fair at best. I think was killed it was the rapid change to grass at the southern part of the map. So, points lost for elevation and rapid change to grass at southern portion.
Story/Instructions: 3.9
Hmm. Well. I expected more. It was not that bad, compared to other scenarios it was average. I dont know why, but I expected more. Maybe I wanted more history that was not off of Wikipedia. Maybe you could have given more about the charachters. Maybe you could have given why Islam was born.
Additional Comments:
Thanks for a good scenario. |
aleksandar_s |
Posted on 05/30/11 @ 05:03 PM
Reviewed! |
Mr UNleash |
Posted on 06/02/11 @ 02:44 AM
Hey hold up. I posted a review a while ago, how is it still not up? |
Kralramazanov
File Author |
Posted on 06/02/11 @ 03:16 PM
Alexander, thanks for reviewing. I will improve myself. I hope. But I must learn English as well... I am making very beautiful Scenarios in Turkish language , but I can't translate them so I can't share them :( |
aleksandar_s |
Posted on 06/02/11 @ 04:44 PM
Mr UNleash, all reviews must be accepted by a admin. If the admin thinks your review is not based on fact, or if it is not complete or fair, they will not accept it. It takes time for the admins to look at the review. If you posted it before mine, then it was probally declined.
Kralramazanov, perhaps you could use Google Translate to translate it word for word. It will give a picture of what you are trying to say. Give it to me in "*.doc" word format and I will proofread it and give it back to you. I can not promise it to be good since I am also not a native english speaker, but I think I am a good english speaker.[Edited on 06/02/11 @ 04:48 PM]
|
Aquril |
Posted on 11/05/11 @ 02:06 AM
I don't think there's been any scenario or let alone a campaign about the birth of Islam(!)
- which was very intresting!
Playability: 4.2
( The replay value is somewhat above the average, as the scenario is better then allot i've download. However there's nothing really new except that it's about Islam,
which hasn't been explored mutch. )
Balance: 3.8
( the Player isn't really in danger except when the enemy launch a full scale attack on Medina )
Creativity: 4
(I don't think there's been any scenario or let alone a campaign about the birth of Islam,
which is a big plus.
The converting in the begining was kinda new,
altough that was it, the rest was old and there's quite allot of other scenarios like this but this held a suprisingly good standard )
Map Design: 4
( Whil
e not historical & geographicly correct at some points {except Medina and Mecka's locations , with } It was pretty nice and suited it's purpouse,
however there wasn't many/new eye candy which could've lifted the scenario even further. )
Story/Instructions: 3.6
( The background history was filled from Wikipedia , which is totally okay =)
the objectives where simple and understandable,
but there wasn't that many cinematics which had more then 1 dialogue message in it,
and that lowered the score. )
Additional Comments:
Above the average one scenario campaign about the birth of Islam and worth the download. |
Kralramazanov
File Author |
Posted on 11/05/11 @ 06:09 AM
Thank you for your comment Aquril. I still don't know how to make longer and good cinematics =) |
Mr UNleash |
Posted on 11/14/11 @ 11:29 PM
Kralramazanov! Haven't seen you in a while :D How've things been? Any new campaigns coming up? |
Kralramazanov
File Author |
Posted on 11/20/11 @ 08:11 AM
Thanks brother asking for me :)) I'm just thinking about my f...king school :D You know, we students must study :)) I have tried to make some campaigns but I couldn't concantre :( |
Pages: [1] 2 » Last » |